Gay men in heterosexual marriage
An Introduction
My client sat in the chair looking down at the floor, glancing up briefly to build eye contact, then darting his eyes back to the carpet. He spoke quietly, as if almost afraid to be heard. He clutched his hands throughout the session, exhibiting all the markers of an anxious man in the throes of shame. He was a unused client to my practice: a married, middle-aged, suburban dad with a high-powered career. A colleague had given him my number months before. It took him a long day to muster the courage to call and build an appointment. Towards the end of our first session he looked up at me and said, “I think I’m in love…with another man. I’m scared and I don’t know what to do.”
I have worked with hundreds of gay men in heterosexual marriages struggling with being in the closet or wanting to appear from it. There is so much about these men that is misunderstood and very few studies or little literature to provide insight. I decided to share my thoughts and research about these men and their struggles at a conference a few years ago. That presentation led to other opportunities to tell their story and of my work with them. Those presentations prompted men to write to
I recently spoke with Bonnie Kaye, author of Direct Wives, Shattered Lives: Stories of Women with Male lover Husbands, among other books, and host of Bonnie Kaye’s Straight Wives Chat Show on BlogTalkRadio. Bonnie has spent much of her adult life first living with and attempting to love a homosexual husband and then helping other women in the same mis-marriage situation. (“Mis-marriage” is Bonnie’s term for “mistake in marriage.” Other people sometimes refer to these relationships using the term “mixed marriage.”)
Source: Shutterstock
Because I know countless same-sex attracted men who were once married to straight women, with varying degrees of short and longer-term happiness and misery, I wanted to discuss this topic, and I wanted to do so from the straight wives’ perspective. Who better to speak with about this than Bonnie Kaye? Our discussion was wide-ranging, beginning with her own marriage to a gay man and moving forward to how she was able to move on post-marriage, eventually becoming a rock for other women in similar situations.
In this post, I have presented part one of this discussion, the story of Bonnie’s marriage and breakup. I will post part two, the aftermath, in a few weeks.
Bonnie Survey Suggests Some Gay Men in Heterosexual Marriages Are Considering Coming Out, Post‑ In India, many gay men and lesbian women gain married under societal and family pressure, and the fact that most people still do not receive homosexuality, forces them to keep their sexual orientation a secret, even after marriage. Figures reveal that nearly 70% of queer men in Mumbai and 80% in smaller cities across Maharashtra are married according to a survey conducted by Mumbai-based Humsafar Trust, an LGBTQ+ activism organization. Across the country, says gay activist Ashok Row Kavi, 75% of the estimated population of million gay men are married. So, what does the recent Supreme Court verdict on decriminalizing Section — that is, effectively decriminalizing homosexuality — mean for these marriages? A recent survey by Celestial body Romeo, a gay online dating app, offers some insight: 28% of gay respondents married to women inform they are considering coming out to their wives. “According to our calculations, around two million married male [sic] will become openly gay,” the site reports. “Considering that most of our members live in vast cities, gays living in the smaller villages are under-represent My Husband’s Not Gay, a show on TLC, has caused an uproar. The negative attention is unfortunate because this could acquire been a show that highlighted mixed-orientation couples and how these couples can actually make their relationships work. Why do some people become so outspoken and judgmental about marriages with one straight and one gay spouse? There are several reasons. These marriages raise concerns about infidelity. They bring out people’s judgments about what marriage should or should not be. In particular, they bring out people’s assessments about monogamy. Finally, these relationships suggest to some people “reparative therapy,” the unethical and impossible claim that a person can be changed from gay to straight. The men in this television program aren’t claiming to be ex-gay nor that they can change their sexual orientation (at least not on the show). They state they are attracted to men but choose not to live as a gay man and their straight wives accept this. People seem to get up in arms when a man says he is not gay but rather simply attracted to men. In our culture, we identify ourselves via a sexual-attraction binary: gay or straight. This is severely limiting .